Study Raises New Concern About Earthquakes and Fracking Fluids
July 17, 2013Protest Minisink Compressor Station
July 20, 2013Message from B. Arrindell, DCS Director:
‘Business’ reasons rule corporate behavior with an eye always toward regaining any territory they may have had to retreat from, so this news has to be seen from their perspective and we must redouble our efforts to make it be only sensible ‘business’ decisions for them to continue on this path.
While we rightfully celebrate the incredible work we have all done – the innumerable termpapers-of-the-day we have all done – must be a very tall stack if in one pile! ..the meetings, comments filed, education sessions with people of all walks of life that we have all done …that we spent our time and efforts in this worthy way and have made it be a ‘sensible business decision’ for them to do what is the right thing to do…this is good. This victory, however, marks only the beginning of the tasks that lie ahead. We will expand the battle and our efforts to help those already caught in the storm.
After all, without health, what do you have?
PRESS RELEASE – July 16, 2013 – for immediate release
Contact: dcs@DamascusCitizens.org phone:845-252-6677
Gas Leases in Northeast PA Abandoned by Newfield/Hess
Abandoned Hess Office in Honesdale, PA (photo by Pat Carullo)
NORTHERN WAYNE COUNTY, PA, JULY 16, 2013 — Hess and Newfield, owners of major gas and oil drilling leaseholds in northeast Pennsylvania, are abandoning leases held for nearly four years in the Delaware River Basin (DRB) and after spending $150 million on those leases, as quoted in AP article this morning.
In letters to all lessors dated July 1, 2013, Newfield Appalachia PA, LLC, advised “…Newfield and Hess have elected to release your lease, thus your lease will not be continued into the development phase.
“Pursuant to the terms of the lease, this letter is notice that Newfield and Hess will file of record a Release of Lease in the offices of the Clerk of County in which the property resides.”
Damascus Citizens for Sustainability(DCS), which started the fight against gas drilling on the East Coast, has obtained several of these letters and the AP has written that all lessors in the area have received them.The complete extent of the withdrawal will be official soon, since changes to leases must be recorded within 30 days.
“There is considerable speculation concerning the reasons,” said Barbara Arrindell, Director of DCS, “but various economic factors may loom large in this decision. Among them may be the extremely high cost of drilling; possible meager gas production; the precipitous downward production decline rate; major stockholders’ discontent with Hess and its risky “scattershot approach to investment” and the continued low price of “dry” gas (gas that has no light oils or ‘natural gas liquids’ in it). Additionally, there may be distinct tax advantages to Hess dumping the leases while it faces mounting business challenges, to say nothing of the public relations nightmare facing the industry with HBO’s airing of Gasland 2, Josh Fox’s latest exposé.
Josh Fox, the creator of the films Gasland and Gasland 2 said, ”I can’t believe it and I can’t stop crying. The companies that leased 80,000 acres in my township, in the upper Delaware River Basin are LEAVING. CANCELING ALL THE LEASES. WE ARE FREE. THANK YOU ALL FRACTIVISTS. THANK YOU EVERYONE FOR THIS AMAZING VICTORY. WE WIN! AND WE WON’T STOP UNTIL WE WIN EVERYWHERE. I’m speechless. This proves that people, organized and passionate can actually win sometimes. In the grand scheme of things, this is a small victory, but it’s HUGE. It’s the Upper Delaware.”
“Yet”, continued Arrindell, “there can be little doubt that this decision also reflects an industry realization that it made a fundamental miscalculation. Even after being limited to only three exploratory wells (now plugged), Hess failed to observe that an educated public was unwilling to accept the industry’s false rhetoric. The claims of environmental safety and supposed benefits to local businesses and workers were recognized as both false and overlooking greater costs to the local economy and quality of life. Unlike the government in Pennsylvania and some other states where protecting the public interest is not taken seriously, the Delaware River Basin Commission is taking a properly cautious regulatory approach. Newfield and Hess could not adjust its investment and management plans to that approach.”
In fact, Carol Collier, Director of the Delaware River Basin Commission recently wrote “All members of the Basin community have a common interest in ensuring that the potential introduction of an industrial activity in the drainage area to these waters occurs only in a manner that does not cause a substantial adverse effect on the outstanding value and vital ecological functions that these waters provide.”
“This is not a surprising decision,” remarked Al Appleton. Appleton, a former New York City Commissioner of Environmental Protection and an international expert on sustainable management of landscapes and water resources and a technical advisor on gas fracking to many organizations, including DCS, continued, “The industry’s economic calculations about the profitability of gas fracking assume that they can treat the environmental, public health, and landscape concerns that gas fracking raises as unimportant and not worthy of significant financial commitment. If these companies had to pay the costs of the damage to the environment, public health, and economic viability of rural landscapes, it would be a far less profitable, but far better business model. Fortunately, in the Pennsylvania portion of the Delaware River Basin, an enormously important environmental resource for over twenty million people, an aroused and aware public, and a responsible regulator have forced the industry to face those costs. This is an important milestone on the path to economic and environmental sustainability, one that Pennsylvania and New York, as well as the United States, are all committed to and must follow. The rule for the future must be that businesses cannot depend on shortcutting environmental and public health concerns as a path to profit. Today, the energy market has had to take a small, but important step towards recognizing the mistake of basing economic strategy on environmentally unsustainable practices.”
Ms. Arrindell, DCS Director declared, “DCS celebrates the Delaware Basin being a little bit cleaner today after these companies have finally faced economic and environmental reality. We should all drink a glass of our clean Delaware water in celebration!”
One lessor affected by Hess’s decision remarked that she was “very happy…Now the work begins educating the other people who made the decision to lease in the first place. This is a huge win for the Delaware River Valley. I just had to share…Thanks to all the grass-roots organizations for your tireless effort to stop the drill.”
Even New York state Attorney General Eric Schneiderman recognized the extraordinary efforts and results of citizens’ protests in New York. Schneiderman said Tuesday at a Post-Standard editorial board meeting, “They have out-organized the oil and gas industry. That’s impressive.”
Joe Levine, DCS co-founder added, “Fracking is intrinsically contaminating and regulations cannot make it safe. This is likely not the last we’ll see of the threatening gas extractors who, with the help of federal, state, and local governments, came to steal our resources and property rights. I think the water contamination and community degradation across PA is catching up with the industry lies that claim drilling is good for us. This feels like a David and Goliath moment. Thank God we still have our water. We regret that so many families across PA cannot say the same.”
DCS says it will continue the fight to keep drilling out of the Delaware River Basin. It seeks to protect everyone’s rights to clean water and air and a life free from the industrialized, scorched earth that accompanies fracking. In addition, DCS is looking to lead the way towards the renewable energy, no-carbon future that is the real hope for long-term environmental and economic health.
Download this Press Release as a pdf
Download sample of typical release letter
Additional analysis by Chip Northrup
